CO129-557-12 Armstrong and Turner v. Estate Duty Commissioner- appeal to Privy Council 18-5-1936 - 2-10-1936 — Page 54

56

16

-

No. 11. Motion for leave to

Full Court. 2nd Novem- ber, 1935.

Michael Howard Turner the present Trustees of the Will of Sir Catchick Paul Chater, K., C.M.G., for leave under Section 17 (2) of Ordinance No. 3 of 1932 appeal to the that the said Trustees be allowed to appeal from the Judgment of His Honour the Chief Justice Sir Atholl MacGregor, Kt., dated the 13th day of June 1935, that the said Judgment be set aside and that Judgment be entered for the said Trustees (Continued) with costs and for an Order that the Estate Duty Commissioner do refund the Estate Duty paid in pursuance of such Judgment together with interest thereon at the rate of 8% per annum from the date of payment to the date of refunding and also do pay the costs of the said Trustees of and incidental to this Appeal.

Dated this 2nd day of November, 1935.

Sd/ DEACONS.

10

57

17

No. 13. Motion to C.M.G., the Full

Court to Set

IN THE MATTER of the Estate of SIR CATCHICK PAUL CHATER, Kt.. late of Victoria in the Colony of Hongkong, aside the Financier, deceased.

and

Judgment of of the Chief

Justice on the Petition appealing from the decision

IN THE MATTER of the Estate Duty of the Com Ordinances 1915 and 1932.

missioner. 10th Decem-

ber, 1935. (Continued)

and

No. 12,

Order giving

leave to

appeal to the

Full Court.

ber, 1935.

To

The Registrar of the Supreme Court and

To the Estate Duty Commissioner and to his Solicitor.

No. 12. Order giring leare to appeal to the Full Court.

Upon hearing Counsel for the Appellants Ex parte IT IS ORDERED 10th Decem- that the Appellants the Honourable Sir William Edward Leonard Shenton, Kt., and Michael Howard Turner the present Trustees of the will of Sir Catchick Paul Chater, Kt., c.M.G., have leave under Section 17 (2) of Ordinance No. 3 of 1932 to appeal to the Full Court from the Judgment of His Honour the Chief 20 Justice Sir Atholl MacGregor, Kt., dated the 13th day of June 1935.

(L.S.)

Dated this 10th day of December, 1935.

Sd/ L. R. ANDREWES,

Registrar.

•

10

IN THE MATTER of the Interpretation Ordinance, 1911.

Between

THE HONOURABLE SIR WILLIAM EDWARD LEONARD SHENTON, Kt, AND MICHAEL HOWARD TURNER.

Appellants.

and

Respondent.

THE ESTATE DUTY COMMISSIONER.

TAKE NOTICE that the Full Court will be moved at 10 o'clock in the fore-noon on Wednesday the 8th day of January 1936 or so soon thereafter as Counsel can be heard by Mr. H. C. Macnamara as Counsel for the above Appellants for an Order that the Judgment of His Honour the Chief Justice 20 Sir Atholl MacGregor, Kt., dated the 13th day of June 1935 be set aside and that Judgment be entered for the Appellants with costs and for an Order that the Estate Duty Commissioner do refund the estate duty paid in pursuance of such Judgment together with interest thereon at the rate of 8% per annum from the date of payment to the date of refunding and also do pay the costs of the Appellants of and incidental to this Appeal.

Dated the 10th day of December, 1935.

No. 13.

Motion to

the Full Court to Set aside the Judgment of

of the Chief Justice on the Petition appealing from the decision

of the Com- missioner.

10th Decem- ber, 1935.

No. 13. Motion to the Full Court to Set aside the Judgment of the Chief Justice on the Petition appealing from the decision of the Commissioner.

In the Supreme Court of Hongkong

APPELLATE JURISDICTION

ESTATE DUTY APPEAL

30

MISC. PROC. No. 31 of 1935.

30

APPEAL NO. 14 OF 1935,

To

The Registrar of the Supreme Court, The Estate Duty Commissioner, and The Crown Solicitor.

Sd/

DEACONS.